Updated: 22 Feb 2025

pony toy softs

Updated: 22 Feb 2025

#1

Best Choice
Mary Meyer Taggies Stuffed Animal Soft Toy, Painted Pony, 11-Inches

9.6

Mary Meyer

Read more

Main highlights

TAGS BABIES LOVE TO EXPLORE: Adorned with interactive and soothing satin loop tags for baby's sensory delight

PAINTED PONY: Premium soft toy horse is made from luxurious white fabric accented with colorful applique polka dots, measures 11-inches

LOTS OF PRETTY PINK: Pony has silky blush pink mane and tail, sparkly pink fabric in her ears, and pretty long eyelashes embroidered for total softness
#2

Value for Money
My Little Pony - Applejack Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

9.4

Symbiote Studios

Read more

Main highlights

Timeless Appeal: With its vibrant colors and endearing design, this plush toy transcends age boundaries, making it an ideal companion for children aged 3 and up, as well as a nostalgic collectible for enthusiasts.

Officially Licensed: An authentic Hasbro product, this collectible plush captures the essence of Applejack, the dependable and resourceful pony from Ponyville, making it a must-have for fans of all ages.

Beloved Character: This 12-inch plush brings the lovable farm gal Applejack from My Little Pony to life, meticulously crafted with high-quality minky fabric for a delightfully soft and cuddly experience.
Curious about how we select the top products for you? Explore How It Works

How do we rank
Our AI-powered platform ranks products using multiple weighted factors from millions of products and user reviews across the web, providing the most valuable and real data. Higher scores rank first.
#3
Douglas Tiny Shetland Pony Plush Stuffed Animal

9.3

Douglas

Read more

Main highlights

Tiny's short, stout legs and charming round belly bring this little horse to life. His stand up design and bright eyed expression will capture the imagination and promote creative play.

Featuring a brown plush coat and a shaggy mane and tail, Tiny the Shetland Pony features realistic traits of this beloved Scottish breed. His durable design is crafted with high quality materials and soft polyester fill for an especially huggable stuffed animal that will hold up to hours of play and cuddling.

Designed in Keene, New Hampshire, U.S.A. by Douglas Cuddle Toys, makers of engaging, distinctive plush toys for over 60 years.
#4
Mary Meyer FabFuzz Calliope Pony Soft Toy Friend,1 months to 200 months

9.2

Mary Meyer

Read more

Main highlights

Measures approximately 11-inches

FabFuzz calliope Pony is a fancy friend crafted from creamy white fabric adorned with delightful spots in pinks, orange, teal and grey

Calliope likes to stand up and show off the colorful ribbons decorating her mane and tail
#5
HollyHOME Horse Stuffed Animal Cute Pony Plush Pretend Play Horse Toys for Girls 11 inches Chocolate

8.9

HollyHOME

Read more

Main highlights

Start imaginative play and make fun with the beautiful horse plush featuring long silky blond hair, realistic leather saddle and cute accessories

Soft plush fur with quality white polypropylene plush filling and sturdy inner construction make the horse an engaging companion for hours of play and hugs while detailed lifelike features and lively stand up pose make her an attractive shelf display

Measures approximately 15.3"L x 5.5"W x 11"H, great size for the little ones to carry around or their baby dolls to fit on
#6
My Little Pony - Fluttershy Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

8.8

Symbiote Studios

Read more

Main highlights

Timeless Companion: Suitable for ages 3 and up, this plush makes an ideal gift for collectors or a cherished friend for imaginative play and adventures.

Sweet and Sincere: Embodying Fluttershy's ability to charm even the mightiest of creatures, this cuddly plush is sure to delight fans of all ages with its accurate depiction of the shy pegasus pony.

Collectible Plush: Officially licensed by Hasbro, this 12-inch Fluttershy plush is expertly crafted from high-quality minky fabric, capturing the gentle and kind essence of the beloved My Little Pony character.
#7
My Little Pony - Pinkie Pie Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

8.7

Symbiote Studios

Read more

Main highlights

Playful and Colorful Plush: Bring the vibrant spirit of Pinkie Pie, the silliest and most entertaining pony from the beloved My Little Pony universe, into your home with this 12-inch plush.

High-Quality Craftsmanship: Expertly crafted from soft minky fabric, this cuddly plush is sure to delight both kids and collectors alike.

Authentic Hasbro Licensing: An officially licensed product from Hasbro, capturing the essence of the My Little Pony franchise in a huggable form.
#8
Douglas Baby Star Pony Snuggler Plush Stuffed Animal

8.6

Douglas

Read more

Main highlights

This engaging Snuggler toy stars our Lil' Star Pony character. Cuddly materials and baby-safe embroidery make this machine washable soft toy safe for infants. Its small size makes this lovey perfect for take along comfort.

Features a silky satin trim that Baby will find irresistible. Tiny embroidered stars and rosy pink cheeks accent Lil' Star Pony's appearance.

Designed in Keene, New Hampshire, U.S.A. by Douglas Cuddle Toys, makers of lovable soft toys for over 60 years.
#9
My Little Pony - Sunset Shimmer Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

8.5

Symbiote Studios

Read more

Main highlights

Vibrant Color and Iconic Style: Embodying the beloved My Little Pony spirit, this plush features a stunning blend of pink and purple hues, capturing the character's signature look.

Enchanting My Little Pony Plush: Meet Sunset Shimmer, a 12-inch tall cuddly companion crafted from high-quality soft minky fabric, perfect for ages 3 and up.

Collectible Wonderland: As part of the renowned My Little Pony franchise, this plush is a must-have for dedicated fans and collectors alike, inviting you to embrace the magic of friendship and imagination.
#10
My Little Pony - Starlight Glimmer Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

8.3

Symbiote Studios

Read more

Main highlights

Iconic Unicorn Beauty: Introducing the Starlight Glimmer plush from the beloved My Little Pony collection by Symbiote Studios, a 12-inch tall stuffed animal crafted with high-quality soft minky fabric, capturing the essence of this powerful magical unicorn.

Exquisite Detail: Meticulously designed to replicate Starlight Glimmer's iconic purple hue and matte finish, this plush toy showcases her unique character and symbolizes the acceptance of individual differences, fostering a message of friendship and inclusivity.

Collectible or Playtime Companion: Whether you're an avid My Little Pony collector or seeking a cuddly companion for your little one, this plush toy is suitable for all ages, offering endless imaginative adventures or a cherished addition to your collection.

Discover top deals and categories on Amazon Check Deals

pony toy softs

Mary Meyer Taggies Stuffed Animal Soft Toy, Painted Pony, 11-Inches

9.6

Main highlights

My Little Pony - Applejack Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

9.4

Main highlights

Douglas Tiny Shetland Pony Plush Stuffed Animal

9.3

Main highlights

Mary Meyer FabFuzz Calliope Pony Soft Toy Friend,1 months to 200 months

9.2

Main highlights

HollyHOME Horse Stuffed Animal Cute Pony Plush Pretend Play Horse Toys for Girls 11 inches Chocolate

8.9

Main highlights

My Little Pony - Fluttershy Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

8.8

Main highlights

My Little Pony - Pinkie Pie Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

8.7

Main highlights

Douglas Baby Star Pony Snuggler Plush Stuffed Animal

8.6

Main highlights

My Little Pony - Sunset Shimmer Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

8.5

Main highlights

My Little Pony - Starlight Glimmer Plush Toy - Officially Licensed Product, Soft and Cuddly Collectible for Fans and Collectors - Ideal Gift for Kids and Adults - Ages 3+

8.3

Main highlights

Similar products on Amazon

My Little Pony Sunny Kids Bedding Super Soft Plush Cuddle Pillow Buddy, One Size, By Franco

My Little Pony Unicorn and Pegasus Plush - Glory - Collector Plushie, Retro Stuffed Toy Animal, Kid, Toddler, Girl, boy, Mom, Birthday, Ages 3+

MiraBall My Little Pony Mystery Expandable Maxi Plush to UNbox, Collectible Squishy and Soft Plush with 4 Surprise, Limited Edition, Great Toy Gift for Kids Aged 3+ (1-Pack)

Aurora® Adorable Mini Flopsie™ Prancer™ Stuffed Animal - Playful Ease - Timeless Companions - Brown 8 Inches

Nueplay 7 Pcs Soft Building Blocks, Sensory Stacking Squeeze Toys with Horse Figure, Newborn Essentials for 6 12 18 Months Baby Toddler Girls

PonyLand: Music Stick Animal - Purple & White Horse - Music Button, Sturdy Two-Piece Stick W/Colorful Soft Plush Animal Head, Toy, Kids Ages 3+

The Petting Zoo Floppy Horse Stuffed Animal Plushie, Gifts for Kids, Wild Onez Wildlife Animals, Horse Plush Toy 9 inches

Pony Plush Toy - Girl Plush Toy - Film Character Image Plush - Soft Pillow, Home Decoration, Festival Gift, Companion Doll - Each 10 inches (5PS)

Aurora World - Dreamy Eyes - 10" Prancer Pony, Brown

sofipal Large Horse Stuffed Animal Plush Toy,Giant Pony Unicorn Plush Doll Gifts for Kids,Valentines,Christmas 35.4"

More products you might like

Sign up and get exclusive special deals